A family throws away their daughter’s Elsa doll. Then, according to them, it comes back. That is only the first rabbit hole in Thread 003 of Internet After Dark. Alé takes Tom through four unsettling accounts, plus a spooky Reddit story: the reportedly haunted Frozen doll in Texas, a woman whose unexplained voices prompted a search for a brain tumor, a Utah river rescue where responders reported hearing a mysterious plea for help, and Japan’s ghost taxi passengers, who began appearing in cab after cab following the 2011 earthquake and tsunami.

Some of these stories start in published reporting and a medical case file. Others spread the way modern folklore does, through firsthand accounts shared online. Either way, the approach is the same: look at what was actually reported, weigh the possible explanations, and sit with the questions that refuse to close.

That is Internet After Dark, a flashlight pointed down the internet’s strangest rabbit holes. Which story would stay with you after the episode ends?